NEWS & ANALYSIS

Why we're falling behind the rest of Africa

Ben Levitas says the ANC govt's racial obsessions are hobbling our progress

How has Africa succeeded in putting its traumatic racial discrimination past behind it? Speak to any businessman doing business in Africa and they will tell you, that ‘race' is not an issue. They will tell you that doing business is not impeded by requirements to have ‘black' partners and that the concept of ‘previously disadvantaged people' does not exist!

Choosing your business partner is based on rational and sound decisions, such as their knowledge of the needs and desires of the local population, rather than the colour of their skin. Employers are free to employ whosoever they choose, and there are no ‘racial quotas' that need to be met.

There are no onerous ‘compliance' issues, which require companies to report on the racial mix of each level of employee and there are no fines for failure to comply. There are no ‘good governance' requirements which require consultants and compliance bodies to vet compliance by companies. Sure there is corruption, but corruption is endemic everywhere in Africa and is not exclusive to Africa.

It may even be worse in South Africa, because the very structure of ‘empowerment' is prone to abuse. Empowerment requires, ‘subjective' factors, such as BBEEE scores, to be considered before awarding contracts. ‘Objective' criteria such as the cheapest price, or the quality of the product or the ability to perform the task on time are put aside, while insidious political considerations take precedence.

Until recently, no special consideration was granted to locally manufactured products, until the DTI woke up, 17 years too late to save South Africa's manufacturing industry, which shrank from 25% of our GNP to about 10%. That is what happens when central planners, mostly with communist world views, and no business experience, plan and run an economy.

The DTI previously could not conceptualise that locally made products, were produced using local labour, because their incentive schemes were more orientated to ‘ownership'. They were more focused on the racial make-up of the enterprise's ownership. So a black owned enterprise importing goods from China, would be a preferred bidder against a ‘white' owned local manufacturer.

South Africa and Zimbabwe are out of sync with the rest of Africa!

Instead of moving on, and putting our awful racial past behind us, we are merely prolonging it. It permeates our society. Our most venerated institutions are being sullied by brazen racialism. Our Judicial system is just such an example. Political interference, by the Ministers of Justice and the President, in processes appointing judges, those we depend on to uphold our wonderful Constitution, are the order of the day.

A constant in all these manoeuvrings, is race-despite all the protestations (and court cases) of the Chief Justice and the Minister of Justice. Good, if not great attorneys and advocates are overlooked only because of the colour of their skins. We need to rehabilitate our legal system and this will require that the process of appointing judges needs to be colour blind and based on merit only.

Even our national obsession, sports, is permeated with racism. Political appointments to top jobs appear to factor in racial considerations. Pressure on coaches to choose teams that represent the racial profile of the general population, is well known. Our African brothers, who base their selections on merit, meanwhile are making great strides in international competitions.

Despite severe financial impediments, Kenya, Ethiopia, Uganda, Ivory Coast, Nigeria and even Botswana attained more medals than team South Africa, in the recent World Athletics Championship in Moscow. They are making progress in other sports too; soccer, cricket and even rugby.

Why after nearly twenty years of freedom do we need to have Black only ‘clubs' or institutions; the Black Management Forum, the Black Lawyers Association, the Black Business Council of South Africa, the Black Farmers and Agriculturalists Association, the National Society of Black Engineers, the Association of Black Securities and Investment Professions, the Black Business Womens Asociation and the list goes on and on.

While it is understandable that some professions may have problems and issues that could be race specific, the sheer plethora and range of ‘black' specific associations, is inconsistent with our non racial constitution and indicates that racial concerns still drive almost every field of endeavour in our society.

Appointments in our parastatals, which should concern all citizens, because their taxes have been used and abused to subsidise these ventures, have also become the domain of racially motivated appointments. All advertisements for these and other positions in the Civil Service, which now employs nearly half of the formally employed workforce in South Africa, grants preference on racial grounds to so-called ‘previously disadvantaged people', (PDI'S) which invariably leads to the exclusion of ‘Whites'.

Admission to tertiary education is a well trod path of racial discrimination, granting preference to so-called PDI's, but it is hurtful to those it excludes and accounts partially for nearly half of students not completing their courses. The cost of this wastage to the national fiscus, is certainly a huge waste of hard earned tax payers money and does the country a huge disservice. It results in many of our best students going overseas and ultimately being lost to the country.

While we need to acknowledge the valid reasons for ‘affirmative action' to rectify the imbalances of the past which deprived ‘black' people of all their basic rights, we also need to stop justifying acts of racism in order to rectify these imbalances. We need to state unequivocally that we are against racism in toto, otherwise we will merely prolong it and ‘kick the can down the road'. Failure to insert a sunset clause into our affirmative action policies, is merely enriching the already rich, slowing economic growth and bleeding our society of its best people.

We need to apply the quote credited to George Santayama that "Those who do not remember history are condemned to repeat it"!

Click here to sign up to receive our free daily headline email newsletter