FEATURES

How Zuma lost his cool... and blew it

Politicsweb.co.za
08 March 2010

And nine other of the top articles from the weekday press

10. Justice Malala's column in The Times on the "good men" in the ANC government

Malala writes that it is important "that we do not forget these individuals. From them there continue to emerge innovative and inspiring attempts to solve our real and urgent problems, such as unemployment, education and health. There are many such individuals - they stand between us and chaos, between us and a precipitous descent into the world of Malema." Yet, such individuals mostly kept quiet in the face of the outrages committed by Thabo Mbeki. The question is why they have gone silent again as "Zuma embarrasses and Malema terrorises"?

9. Tim du Plessis' column in Beeld asking how long President Jacob Zuma will survive

Du Plessis recalls a past discussion with a black editor who noted that the three prerequisites for ANC leaders in the past were that they had to be intelligent (and well-educated), have integrity, and come from prominent families in their community. Du Plessis notes that Zuma is no fool, and that family origin is of less importance than it used to be. However, when it comes to the issue of integrity the big problem arises:

"Iemand met integriteit sou nie gehuiwer het om hof toe te gaan om sy onskuld te bewys as hy werklik in sy onskuld geglo het nie. Pleks daarvan is soveel politieke druk uitgeoefen dat die vervolgingsgesag inligting wat op 'n ongerymde wyse bekom is as verskoning gebruik het om die vervolging teen Zuma te staak. Dit sou iemand met integriteit gegrief het dat Shaik 'n hoogs verdagte mediese parool kry terwyl almal weet Shaik is heeltemal gesond genoeg om in die tronk te wees. Iemand met integriteit sou nie Julius Malema se bombasme en openbare ploertigheid verduur het nie. So 'n mens sou ook nie die Mafia-agtige wyse verdedig waarop Malema hom verryk deur tenderpreneurskap nie. 'n Leier van integriteit sou tewens nooit eens toegelaat het dat Malema die politieke monster word wat hy vandag is nie. Net 'n president met 'n integriteitsprobleem sou 'n gediskrediteerde amptenaar soos Menzi Simelane aangestel het in die kritiek belangrike pos van vervolgingshoof."

8. Anthony Butler's article in Business Day on the route SA politics is likely to take after the World Cup party is over:

Butler notes: "If the stadiums are full and international visitors embrace the vuvuzela as their own, Zuma's popularity may be buoyed by soaring national pride. Should violence or organisational disarray mar the event, however, national shame will be followed by a yearning for recrimination. The months immediately after the tournament seem destined to be filled with desperate power struggles. Yet it is not certain that Zuma is terminally damaged and cannot continue as African National Congress (ANC) president for a second term. The ANC in KwaZulu- Natal has its own plans for the succession and cannot afford to see Zuma depart early. It has invested heavily in the security state that will play a major role in any prolonged contest for power."

7. Derek Schultze's letter in The Times on how preferential procurement policies have allowed tenderpreneurship to take root in the system:

Schultze notes that under the rules adopted in the late 1990s "the evaluation of tenders is based on a portion of the tender price only (80% or 90% as the case may be). The balance (10% to 20%) is assessed on what is known as the ‘preferential procurement point system', which awards points, for instance, for the extent a company is owned by HDIs, women, the disabled and members under 35. Other preferential considerations include labour usage, HDI participation at all levels of management, as well as to what extent other ‘affirmable business enterprises' are involved in the tender. It is quite possible, then, that a client (a government entity) could pay up to 20% more for services rendered in a contract in a case in which the lowest bidder with zero preferential points (for instance) is not awarded the contract. As most of the preferential considerations in the tender documents are highly subjective in nature, the adjudication of tenders has become open to all sorts of manipulation and abuse."

6. Alec Russell's article in the Financial Times on how the cartoonish caricature of Jacob Zuma obscures far more serious issues:

Russell notes growing concern among Western investors at the direction the Zuma government is taking. These investors want Zuma "to go beyond equivocating and mollifying the feuding powerbrokers of his rowdy alliance" and start leading. "Julius Malema, the demagogic leader of the ANC's powerful Youth League, is touring the country with incendiary demands, including nationalising South Africa's mines. The government has belatedly said this is not policy, but business is concerned that Mr Malema has not been hauled over the coals. At the same time, party barons are sparring over the appointments of chief executives to the major state entities as if they were personal fiefs - these sectors need competent qualified managers, not apparatchiks. For all Mr Zuma's talk of a new broom, the voracity of ANC bigwigs for business deals, apparent under his predecessor, grows apace."

5. John Kane Berman's column in Business Day on the ferment within government over labour market reform:

Kane Berman argues that COSATU's loud protests against any possible changes are a reflection of weakness. The power of the union federation is waning as employers and job seekers cut deals outside the rigid formal labour market system. Its strength, he argues, is eroding in other ways. "Its penetration of the workforce is declining thanks to the rise in unemployment, which its own insistence on an inflexible labour market has helped to cause. At the same time, it is becoming more dependent on the state as public-sector unionisation increases while private-sector unionisation declines. Third, Cosatu is so obsessed with politics and patronage that it has neglected grassroots organisation. This is one of the reasons it relies (with impunity, given government timidity) on violence to ensure participation in strikes."

Kane Berman warns: "Cosatu should take a look at the history of white trade unions in SA. They too were dependent on their alliance with the ruling National Party (NP) to protect their jobs from (black) competition. When the growth of black grass-roots unionism changed the configuration of power on the factory floor in the 1970s and 1980s, the NP withdrew its support from the white unions and they were done for."

4. Rob Brand's post on his weblog critiquing the Supreme Court of Appeal judgment ruling that it was defamatory for The Citizen to call Robert McBride a criminal and murderer

Brand argues that the SCA's ruling is "based on a misunderstanding" of the amnesty process of the TRC. Perpetrators were "offered a trade-off: amnesty in return for full disclosure. The legislation did not require us to forgive the perpetrators or condone their actions. The intention was to set the record straight; to find out the truth so that we will never repeat the abuses of the past. To argue, as SCA did, that we may now not rely on that truth to express negative opinions about people who have been granted amnesty is just plain wrong. Am I not allowed to comment with distaste about the past of, say, Brigadier Jack Cronje, the former security policeman who, along with four of his henchmen, was granted amnesty for 47 killings of activists? If Cronje were to be offered a high-level post in the police in the new South Africa, would I be liable for defamation if I commented that he would be unsuitable for the position?"

3. The Daily Maverick's photo of ANCYL President Julius Malema being poured a glass of pink Moët et Chandon in front of the impoverished masses bussed into his birthday celebrations:

It is a scene that if made up would, as P.J. O'Rourke once put it, get you "drummed right out of the Subtle Fiction Writers League". Phillip de Wet reports that Malema told the assembled gathering: "I was made by the struggle of the poor. I'm a product of a poor family, and I'll remain humble before the poor."

2. The Mercury report on how SARS had taken possession of R16,5m worth of luxury vehicles belonging to the prominent Durban tenderpreneurs S'bu and Shauwn Mpisane:

Wendy Jasson da Costa reports that the couple quietly handed over a Rolls-Royce Phantom convertible (valued at R7m) and two white Lamborghinis (valued at R9,5m) to the taxman as surety for outstanding debts. "It is understood that the Mpisanes separately and through their various business ventures owed the taxman close on R50m, but it is unknown how much they have coughed up already or what amount is outstanding. The Mercury reported last month that among the couple's woes was a demand from the taxman for them to pay. Although it was speculated that the matter could go to court, it appears that the Mpisanes opted to co-operate and have struck a deal."

1. The Star report on Jacob Zuma's intemperate response to the nasty personal attacks directed against him in the British press ahead of his state visit to the United Kingdom:

Zuma told Moshoeshoe Monare: "When the British came to our country, they said everything we are doing was barbaric, was wrong, inferior in whatever way. Bear in mind that I'm a freedom fighter and I fought to free myself, also for my culture to be respected. And I don't know why they are continuing thinking that their culture is more superior than others, those who might have said so. The British have done that before, as they colonised us, and they continue to do this, and it's an unfortunate thing."

Click here to sign up to receive our free daily headline email newsletter

Services

Subscribe to newsletters
News feeds


Share this article

Facebook Facebook Google Google Laaik.it Laaik.it
Yahoo! Yahoo! Digg Digg del.icio.us del.icio.us


 

Comments

If you come across comments that are injurious, defamatory, profane, off-topic or inappropriate; contain personal attacks or racist, sexist, homophobic, or other slurs, please report them and they will be removed.
 
 responses to this article

This Herdboy is barbaric; what culture? Is sleeping with u r friend's daughter an african culture?
Stop speaking on behalf of the rest of us; the media is right, you are such a disgrace barbaric std 3 village boy? The only thing that interest you is having sex even if the women pleads for mercy coz she is HIV . Why haven't u declare ur interests you . .more

by Mute Fool on March 08 2010, 14:11
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Integrity
I just love Tim du Plessis' exposition of those facts which point to Zuma's total lack of integrity. How on earth the ANC can STAND having such a slimy oafish twit as President is beyond any reasonable person's comprehension.

I also love a . .more

by flebus on March 09 2010, 00:33
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

I thought Mbeki was not a good guy, a small man with no leadership or people skills
He also seemed to dislike whites. However this Zuma guy is really bad for SA I think. He is so wrong you wonder if they could find a less appropriate person. He somehow managed to avoid his day in court (he must have had something to hide?). He will not . .more

by Buffoon for sure on March 09 2010, 02:30
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Mbeki and Zuma
Mbeki was really the pits; a small-minded racist who thought he was a great intellectual, and whose obsession with race and his imagined intelligence led him into denialism wrt HIV/AIDS, resulting in the unnecessarily early deaths of hundreds of thousands . .more

by mpho on March 09 2010, 09:09
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

It's my kulcha ...
to be dishonest, to be corrupt, to fraternise with known criminals, to fornicate with reckless abandon ... it's my kulcha

by Is this what it means to be African? on March 09 2010, 09:10
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Justice Malala...an overated fooll
Justice Mala is one of the dumbest political analysts in this country! Every thing that this fool has commented on with regards to the ANC and its leaders were proved spectacularly wrong! Its amazing how newspapers are still wasting their money to pay . .more

by Iskariot on March 09 2010, 09:29
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Try and prod the British into lifting Sanctions on Bob(not Zim)
and you might end up with an SAS trained guard breaking your fat finger off.
I like how these guys (the little poet did it too) go to Britain and America with their begging bowls in hand and try and dictate policy while clapping their beggar hands . .more

by Fred on March 09 2010, 09:44
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Courtesy begets courtesy
Whoever is responsible for this column has no respect for the President of this country otherwise he would not have published the very first letter by Mute Fool.I am asking that restraint be exercised in hurling insults to our President.Whether you . .more

by ZAPATA on March 09 2010, 09:55
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

K**
If Zuma is a culture vulture, he should join the `Kaapse Akademie Kultuur"

Better known as K**.

by Turd on March 09 2010, 10:10
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@ZAPATA
Respect is earned !
He hasn't and if you don't realise its not cos he is black its cos he is useless and a 21st century embarrassment to our country, then you Sir are the Racist.
Remove the log from your eye before you attempt the splinter in . .more

by Fred on March 09 2010, 11:06
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@Zapata ....We were wrong....
In moderating our Criticism of the last president the ANC chose for us.
At the time all the critics were called racists too when they argued that mBeki was a myopic fool and was murdering his own people.
Today we all know that he and his . .more

by Fred on March 09 2010, 11:16
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

The clown Racist
Funny ( or not anymore ) how criticism of any black person in this country label you as racist - even if the criticism is just. Yes he is our president ZAPATA but please open your eyes, or am I also racist now ......ha ha ha

by Kosie on March 09 2010, 11:36
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Criticising the top
@ZAPATA
If you read the British and French papers you would understand that what this column and they are saying about Mr Zuma is no different to their treatment of their own leaders. Le Canard excoriated both Sarkozy and Mitterand, and The Daily . .more

by john kalala on March 09 2010, 12:07
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Oh no zapata not you again - idiot
Birds of a feather flock together and you zapata have a toilet for a brain. Go and spew your love and admiration for you 'president' somewhere else. Us grown ups are having a discussion about how inadequate zuma is and how incompetent he and his ilk are. . .more

by YT on March 09 2010, 12:29
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

top 10
Great all 10 of you - You have brains and are respectable.

by tops on March 09 2010, 12:30
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Zuma
Jeez but you guys just don't get it do you! when Vorster and Botha wagged their fingers at the world it was to parliamentry standing ovations.

by Roger the Lodger UK on March 09 2010, 12:31
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@Zapata; ke le ndaki broer waka (i'm an african) nee racist!
But JZ is ke Prez ya ditlatla (fools) like you. Fact is, he sleeps with his friends's daughters even if they tell him they are HIV (this is not african culture and not an insult). Let him & Juju continue lead ANC of thugs into self destruction... ga re . .more

by Mute Fool on March 09 2010, 12:57
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

The Mbeki disaster
Another disaster we have to thank Mbeki for, is the throwing to the wolves of the SA economy through the catastrophic and unconstitutional policy of cadre deployment.

The ensuing corruption and tenderpreneurship will burgeon further under Zuma, . .more

by fuzz on March 09 2010, 13:02
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

It's Zuma's fault the truth about him is insulting

and it is surely our right, and even our duty, to speak the truth. A fornicator is a fornicator, whether he is president or not, so why should we not say, given the facts, that the president is a fornicator? If this is an "insult", then so be . .more

by flebus on March 09 2010, 13:13
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Cut and paste drivel
This supposed article is just a hurried cut and paste. There is nothing original or new. Same old same old bash, bash, bash. A toltaly incoherent soup of diverse right wing mutterings. No attempt at an argument or making a point. It sounds like someone is . .more

by ANC Man on March 09 2010, 13:28
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@ Iskariot
Please list me the 10 imost recent utterances that were all proven wrong. No one person only talks drivel, not even Julius!

by Nic on March 09 2010, 14:01
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Some headlines...
of the media does not correspond to the contents of the true story. Anyone who believes and acts on what the media is saying and printing should consider to have their mental faculties examined. The Britons came and confiscated our land and resources . .more

by Pierre on March 09 2010, 14:18
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@ANC Man
Considering that less than 2000 people chose Zuma, "the people will govern" is rather inappropriate.
As for the battle for the Soul of the ANC......
That corrupt, burned out crispy, festering, puss filled pimple on the A** of the nation can . .more

by Fred on March 09 2010, 16:04
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@ANC man
Zuma an ethical unbribeable man?

You brainless sycophant.

by Andy on March 09 2010, 16:11
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@ANC Man
You say : "The biggest fear of the elite is having an ethical unbribable man as the President. All the ignorant people who go along with the anti Zuma rhetoric are either unable to make a clear judgment for themselves, or are paid in brown envelopes. The . .more

by fuzz on March 09 2010, 17:01
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

"the hyperintelligent Thabo Mbeki...."
Mr Mpho, since you comment about this that "Mbeki was really the pits; a small-minded racist who thought he was a great intellectual..." I would like to add that not only did Mr Mbeki thought that he (himself) is a great intellectual, but that Tim du . .more

by JVR on March 09 2010, 18:27
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

qpoDREEWWrmxidjiqnxlQNDPQ
The fact of the matter is.... at grass root level...all the stakeholders...zzzz......

by Jo Jo Jo... on March 09 2010, 20:30
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Tim du Plessis' faux pas
Yep, you're right, Tim was pretty stupid to have misread that situation so badly. Fact is Mbeki was hated by factions in the alliance to the extent that ANYONE else would have been preferable.

To my shame I must admit at one stage I also thought . .more

by mpho on March 09 2010, 23:30
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Here Zooma goes again!
He falls just short of shouting racist or attacking the colonialists on the one hand, then proceeds to prove that he does not take global warming seriously by demonstrating by his own actions that he is willing to faunicate with anything that moves and . .more

by Sipho on March 09 2010, 23:56
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

The Chinese curse, Mr Mpho

You are right on about Mbeki.

I would not call him names, but I have realised since the mid-1980s, once I gave the ANC men a good look, what they were all about. I know I repeat myself, but one cannot understand Mbeki without reading up . .more

by JVR on March 10 2010, 02:35
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@Fred
I think you are romanticising about what you think the people want. If we had a direct election for the Presidency tomorrow. Jacob Zuma would win hands down. At least with a 60% majority. Remember that before last years election he had been attacked . .more

by ANC man on March 10 2010, 12:40
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@ Andy
Where is your evidence that Jacob Zuma has ever been bribed. Where? . 8 years of investigation and a paltry amount of money handled by the man who handled his financial affairs at the time. With no evidence of any kind to link to a bribe. The amount in . .more

by ANC man on March 10 2010, 12:49
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

@fuzz
Your words "I go along with much of the anti Zuma rhetoric" - Yes Ok
" I am able to make a clear judgment for myself" - So you believe
" so why haven't I been paid in a brown envelope? " - Because you just go along with.

by ANC man on March 10 2010, 12:56
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

You are correct, ANC man...

ANC man -- I agree with you about this all.... If there is an election tomorrow in SA directly for President, Mr Zuma would trounce everybody else, at least 60% of the vote, all in the Eastern Half of SA. The Western and Western-Central part, well, . .more

by JVR on March 10 2010, 17:10
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it


Name
Subject
Comment