SANEF to apply as Amicus Curiae in the Citizen Constitutional Court Challenge
The South African National Editors' Forum (Sanef) has decided to apply to be an amicus curiae in The Citizen's Constitutional Court challenge against the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) ruling in McBride vs Citizen.
SANEF has taken the decision because it is deeply concerned that through a majority SCA ruling, a law intended to foster reconciliation in the country has the extraordinary power to censor historical fact by declaring that a particular conviction did not take place and that to state that the conviction did occur is "false".
While SANEF is not involving itself in The Citizen's views on McBride, the organisation is expressing its deep concern about the wording of the amnesty legislation which turns fact into falsehood and campaigns for it to be amended.
The SCA decision was based on a section in the Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act Act which states that amnesty expunges the conviction and sentence from all official records and also that "the conviction shall for all purposes .... be deemed not to have taken place"-the sentence that turns fact into falsehood.
The SCA ruling raises a fundamental issue of press freedom in that it would compel the media to be party to the falsification of history, with dire consequences for their credibility.