South Africa is not transforming - COSATU

Patrick Craven
04 August 2011

Federation angered that whites still make up 73,6% of top management

Employment Equity Act is failing to transform South Africa

The Congress of South African Trade Unions is angered by the report of the Commission for Employment Equity. It reveals that whites - who make up only 12.1% of the economically active population - still occupy 73.1% of ‘top management' positions. African people - who make up 73.6% of the population - occupy only 12.7%, Indians 6.8% and coloureds 4.6%.

These figure show a minimal improvement from 2006, when blacks constituted 11.3% of top management and whites 74.9%.

At the lower ‘senior management' level, the situation is fractionally better, but whites also still dominate, with 64.1% of those positions, compared to 17.6% for Africans 7% for coloureds and 9% for Indians. The number of whites in these positions has dropped by just 6.8% since 2006, while the number of black people had increased by 4.2%, Indians by 1.4% and coloureds by 1.2%.

Labour Minister Mildred Oliphant says she is "disappointed" at the slow pace of reform at top management and she is determined "to take drastic measures to deal with the situation".

It is more than "disappointing" however; it is a national disgrace that we have done so little after 17 years of democracy to reverse the racial imbalances we inherited from the days of apartheid. The Employment Equity Act is failing abysmally to transform the discrimination inherited from apartheid. In the private sector most employers do not even submit EE reports and those that are submitted reveal that virtually nothing has changed.

As CEE chairperson Mpho Nkelo says, at the current rate of change it would be 127 years before the racial breakdown in top management was representative of the racial breakdown of the total economically active population.

Thirteen years ago in 1998, when the Employment Equity Act was passed, COSATU called on all South Africans to give it support, saying it was the only way in which we could achieve national reconciliation and transformation in our country.

It is a call that has clearly not been heeded in the boardrooms of business, where top executives have been helping themselves to bigger and bigger salary increases and bonuses, while fighting against wage increases for their workers and doing nothing to relinquish any of their control over the country's economy and their ownership of its wealth.

We cannot claim that we have succeeded in building a non-racial democracy, when apartheid still lives on in the economy and every aspect of our lives. On average white workers earn 8 times as much as black workers in manufacturing industry. An average African man earns in the region of R2 400 per month, whilst an average white man earns around R19 000. The racial income gap is therefore roughly R16 800 among males.

Most white women earn in the region of R9 600 per month, whereas most African women earn R1 200 per month. The racial income gap in monthly incomes among women is therefore R8 400. On average, white women also earn eight times more than their African counterparts.

It is the same story in relation to black economic empowerment, which has failed to bring about any meaningful change. Almost all the 20 top paid directors in JSE listed companies remain white males.

Urgent action is required to start enforcing these laws more effectively. The Freedom Charter said that "all apartheid laws and practices shall be set aside". We have changed the laws but clearly not all the practices!

COSATU will do everything possible to assist government in working to achieve a society in which the distribution of wealth reflects the population distribution of South Africa, while fighting just as hard to achieve greater economic equality within the world's most unequal society.

Statement issued by Patrick Craven, COSATU national spokesperson, August 4 2011

Click here to sign up to receive our free daily headline email newsletter


Subscribe to newsletters
News feeds

Share this article

Facebook Facebook Google Google
Yahoo! Yahoo! Digg Digg



If you come across comments that are injurious, defamatory, profane, off-topic or inappropriate; contain personal attacks or racist, sexist, homophobic, or other slurs, please report them and they will be removed.
 responses to this article

Not transforming
Of course not you dumb F.ucks , you atre too F. ing stupid , you remember the days of liberation before EDUCATION .


Remember the days , . .more

by Charlie on August 04 2011, 23:11
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

meant to be , are .

by Charlie on August 04 2011, 23:12
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

985 = 98%

I am so pissed of with how f. ucking stupid they are and their stupid moron I* .72 comments .

by Charlie on August 04 2011, 23:14
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

cosatu continues to pump the race statistics bandwagon, while it claims
non-racialism & continues to hide behind the antique sacp managed 'freedom' charter, & while comrades unashamedly continue to milk to taxpayers whenever they can manufacture a chance - no word of course on any race stats of corruption antics. What a sham. . .more

by gab ok on August 05 2011, 04:02
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Well, Charlie, and I thought Malema was bad; but your lack of coherent thinking and your penchant for abusive language is an indication of a very uneducated person with a big chip on their white shoulder. If the young blacks had not put liberation before . .more

by john kalala on August 05 2011, 06:18
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

More whites than balcks in business??
Ha Ha - The chickens are coming home to roost. You all preached liberatuion before education 'cos you KNEW the onley way to control the mjority was to KEEP THEM STUPID, A TRICK THE APARTHEID GOVT WORKED OUT LONG AGO. Don't blame the past - blame your All . .more

by Realist on August 05 2011, 06:27
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

"Whites still rule the Economy"
More whites than balcks in business??
Ha Ha - The chickens are coming home to roost. You all preached liberation before education 'cos you KNEW the only way to control the majority was to KEEP THEM STUPID, A TRICK THE APARTHEID GOVT WORKED OUT LONG . .more

by Realist on August 05 2011, 06:30
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Shame Patrick - Sadly still the colour angle.
Mr. Craven, as an educated man, you are obviously simply stating the party line rhetoric, which is acceptable or you would have to do what the NATS did - give up what you believe, even though it no longer applies.
I note however that you are quite . .more

by citiZEN on August 05 2011, 07:52
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

a disappointing disgrace
The only 'disappointing' and disgraceful' thing about all this is the government's inability to implement a sound education system (that actually teaches the vast majority of children / youth) skills that will make them employable in the 21st century and . .more

by d on August 05 2011, 09:43
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

As Transformation Practitioners, we are not protected
In as much as Cosatu has been going on and on about transformation, when a few brave and dedicated people like myself start to tackle issues of transformation in the worksplace, we get dismissed because we are seen to upset whites or the big boss. While . .more

by Livid on August 05 2011, 10:13
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

white classification ?
why exclude the whites all the time in discussions, and the call the rest of the population as Africans? (a form of hate speech, my oppinion)
iam born here iam a African and proud of it, your way of talk is bringing back appartheid against which we . .more

by janz on August 05 2011, 11:21
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Shouldn't people be appointed according to merit and whether they are able to do the job? It seems our goverment is more concerned about what colour a person is then whether they are capable.

by Shangwari on August 05 2011, 19:25
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Democratise racial mix of "top management positions"
Take the decision of the acceptability or otherwise of mostly white top managers away from Government. Advertise widely how companies "score" and let the customer decide who to buy from. Then also look for difference in spending patterns between the . .more

by Steve Spottiswoode on August 06 2011, 21:40
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it