Secrecy Bill: The battle isn't over - Lindiwe Mazibuko

Lindiwe Mazibuko
25 April 2013

DA PL says legislation, though improved, still doesn't pass constitutional muster

Secrecy Bill: This fight is not over

Note to editors: The following speech was delivered today by DA Parliamentary Leader, Lindiwe Mazibuko MP, during the Consideration of the Protection of State Information Bill in Parliament.

Hon Deputy Speaker:

This fight is not over.

Just over one year ago, this House was faced with a piece of legislation that threatened our democracy's foundational values of freedom and openness.

In response to this threat, Parliament sprung into life. With unprecedented opposition co-operation, the government was forced into a series of U-turns.

In the National Assembly and the NCOP, we refused to back down because we knew the dangers that the Bill presented. 
I wish to pay tribute to the DA members who have worked tirelessly ever since to improve this Bill: the Honourable Dene Smuts, the Honourable David Maynier; and in the NCOP, the Honourable Alf Lees and Darryl Worth.

Working with members of other opposition parties, we were unflagging in our determination to fight this unconstitutional Bill.

Outside parliament too, a well-organised campaign demonstrated the determination of all of our citizens to defend South Africa's hard won democracy.  

Our independent media and civic organisations are strong.

Hon Deputy Speaker:

There are two foundational principles which I believe are widely accepted in this House across party political boundaries.

The first is that democracy cannot work when security exceeds its proper limits.

The second is that the media cannot function when important information is suppressed. Bad governments thrive under the cloak of darkness. Those who have nothing to hide have nothing to fear. 

The danger of this Bill was that its provisions could have shielded those who engage in corruption and shady acts.

It was also tabled within the context of a revived securocrat state.

The cover up of the Presidential Handbook;

The secrecy behind the spending of R206million of public money on the President's Nkandla homestead;

The circumstances surrounding the Marikana tragedy;

And the continued failure to appoint a head of the SIU;

All of these related events point to how the government has attempted to close down the democratic state.

The Bill could have been used to keep the lid on embarrassing information about the government. And it could have been deployed to prevent new information emerging in the future.

So we held the line and the outcome was a greatly improved Bill. But we cannot stop here because, Hon Deputy Speaker, this fight is not over.

The fact remains that this Bill is still flawed because Parliament does not have the power to legislate on matters which are exclusive provincial competences.

From the beginning, the Bill ought to have been tagged as a Section 76 bill to allow for proper provincial scrutiny.

Honourable members will know that the Constitutional Court has in the past declared Acts of Parliament ‘null and void' because they were not correctly processed as Section 76 bills.

This is exactly what happened with the passage of CLARA, the Communal Land Rights Act.

In our view, this Bill equally does not pass constitutional muster.

Hon Deputy Speaker,

I sense that there are honourable members in the government benches who know in their hearts that this Bill, as it stands, is unconstitutional.

The question is, will they stand up and be counted?

Will members of COSATU continue the fight after their leaders' valiant presentation to the Ad Hoc committee on this Bill?

Will you stand on principle and take up the fight with us?

Last year, we know that 35 members of COSATU voted for the Secrecy Bill even though  publically, their organisation opposed it.

Today, their legacy is at stake. I hope those honourable members will do the right thing.

Hon Deputy Speaker,

The fight is not over.

This House has a grave responsibility to ensure that every piece of legislation we pass is aligned to the Constitution. 

We will therefore be seeking a legal opinion from senior council on the constitutionality of the entire Bill.

And if the majority party passes this Bill today, we will petition the Honourable President to send the Bill back to the National Assembly under Section 79 of the constitution.

This is an opportunity for President Jacob Zuma to provide real leadership. Let him demonstrate to South Africa that he will stand by and stand up for the constitution. 

In the event that this should fail, I have already begun to lobby the leaders of other political parties in Parliament, to refer the law directly to the constitutional court in terms of section 80 of the constitution.

Hon Deputy Speaker,

We have a historic opportunity to stand up, across party lines, for our constitution today.

Let us do the right thing. Let us get this Bill right. 

I thank you.

Issued by the DA, April 25 2013

Click here to sign up to receive our free daily headline email newsletter



If you come across comments that are injurious, defamatory, profane, off-topic or inappropriate; contain personal attacks or racist, sexist, homophobic, or other slurs, please report them and they will be removed.
 responses to this article

speaking truth to power
Thank you, Lindiwe Mazibuko. South Africans must fight every inch to recover the lost ground that has been taken over by the new securocrats, on behalf of - to shield - a failing regime and its covert purposes. We are a republic, res publica, a common . .more

by Peter Merrington on April 26 2013, 03:28
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Secrecy bill
You ave got ernegy and resources to fight ANC ,it doesn't matter how te they accommodate you Lindiwe, you can't even if when you have lost because of your no of constituents in parliament you the run to court

I m of te view at our system must . .more

by Dukes on April 26 2013, 06:36
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Example of a supporter of the Vile ANC
Simply read the nonsensical drivel spewing forth from "Dukes" and you will get a reasonable idea of the calibre of the average ANC supporter.

A vile, racist, corrupt party supported by morons.

by Democrat on April 26 2013, 07:36
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Congrats, Lindiwe
Excellent speech, Ms Mazibuku! Fearless and straight. Yes-voters of this Bill should be ashamed of themselves. The tragedy is, they will not.

by Theresa Papenfus on April 26 2013, 09:37
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

Yes-voters of this Bill
As long the ANC has the overwhelming majority in parliament and the average voting ANC supporter has blinkers on ,,,the ANC will dictate the outcome of any debate …..

by Manfred Schmidt on April 26 2013, 09:54
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

...was forced into a series of U-turns....
But the document was put out for public comment and mostly the comments were incorporated...there was no U-turn, just the normal processing...

It could be worse this woman could be leader of the official opposition in parliament....oh wait.... . .more

by . on April 26 2013, 10:23
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it

A good speech.
And the usual facile comment from the . cadre. Lindiwe should do her proof-reading more diligently; there is the world of difference between "council" and "counsel", and she should not use the former when the latter is appropriate.

Thus, rather . .more

by Mute Fool on April 26 2013, 21:17
Find this comment inappropriate? Report it