DA calls for hearings on NRF action against astronomer and government's investments in space
I have written to the chairperson of the Science and Technology portfolio committee, Dr Nqaba Ngcobo, requesting urgent appearances before the committee of the Minister of Science and Technology Naledi Pandor and relevant officials to brief us fully on the disciplinary hearing of renowned astronomer Prof Phil Charles and the media announcements of the ramping up of government's involvement in the space industry.
Both these issues have sparked considerable public interest and debate about the wisdom of government's plans and actions.
The National Research Foundation's disciplinary hearing of Prof Charles was due to conclude yesterday and, whatever its outcome, I believe it is vital for the health of our international scientific relationships that there be full disclosure of what transpired, and that the reasons behind the NRF's actions openly discussed (see report).
In response to a letter I wrote to the Minister last week she responded that she shared my view that "transparency in the matter will help allay concerns about the standing of our scientific institutions and will therefore raise your concerns with the NRF."
On the issue of the government's increasing enthusiasm to become involved in the space industry I believe there needs to be an explanation and discussion of their vision and plans at a time when the Department of Science and Technology is making considerable cuts to the budget allocations to many of its initiatives that address the country's developmental needs.
Our national infrastructure is crumbling because government departments have been lax about their housekeeping chores. The priority should be to bolster what we have in place before seeking to invest in expensive new endeavours.
I know space science is one of DST's five grand challenges but I am sceptical that the international business opportunities for South Africa to have its own launching facility are that compelling. Launching SumbandilaSat was expensive because South Africa chose not to make the sound financial decision - which would have been to use launching facilities in the West.
I also realise that we have a wealth of scientific talent that is keen to keep at the leading-edge of their fields. We don't want to lose them to other countries. So, if the government is determined to go ahead with this, I would strongly urge that it proceed only if we can secure an international partnerships with countries and enterprises that are committed to the peaceful use of space technology (as South Africa is) and will not use our launching facility for any military or defence application, and that disaster-management applications are open to public scrutiny.
We also have to consider the environmental and business impact of developing a full-blown commercial launching site in the Overberg. This will have a considerable impact on farming and tourist operations out there.
I urge a through process of public participation hearings soonest.
Statement issued by Marian Shinn, MP, Democratic Alliance shadow minister of science and technology, February 24 2010
Click here to sign up to receive our free daily headline email newsletter
