EWC dampens investment enthusiasm in US – IRR

Frans Cronje says uncertainty created has acted to undercut Ramaphoria

EWC dampens investment enthusiasm in US – IRR’s Frans Cronje

The South African government’s ‘repeated commitment to expropriation without compensation has been allowed to compete for airtime in the United States with the narrative of reform that came out of the ANC leadership change in December 2017,’ says IRR CEO Frans Cronje.

This had created ‘great uncertainty’ in the US, and ‘has dampened investment enthusiasm’.

Cronje was commenting after the first week of private and public meetings in Washington that form part of the IRR’s international campaign this month to generate support for protecting and extending the property rights of all South Africans.

Cronje said: ‘One thing that became quite apparent during our first week in the United States was the degree of confusion and misinformation about the EWC proposal. It was assumed in some places that the proposal related mainly to land and the further implications were not well understood, especially where it came to regulatory expropriations – in the security industry for example.

‘But regardless of the misunderstandings, the EWC question is clearly a source of great uncertainty and has dampened investment enthusiasm following the political changes that occurred in South Africa in December.’

‘There was a considerable degree of surprise at just how poorly thought through the proposal was, that no detailed plans for implementation had been put forward, and that South African policy makers would risk the investment reputation of the country to the extent that they have done.

‘Africa and let alone South Africa is not a high-profile issue on the America political and policy agenda. That is why it is so important that when South Africa gets on the Washington agenda it is for the right reasons – and unfortunately the Government’s repeated commitment to EWC narrative has been allowed to compete for airtime with the narrative of reform that came out of the ANC leadership change in December 2017.’

Cronje used his appearance at the Cato Institute in Washington on June 20 to launch the IRR’s latest report on EWC, ‘Empowering the State, Impoverishing the People’.

The report warns that ‘the undermining of property rights in South Africa has serious implications both for American investors in South Africa and for the strategic interests of the United States’.

In his speech at the Cato Institute, titled Will South Africa become Africa’s Venezuela?’, Cronje said there was no question of the importance of ‘addressing historical dispossession’, but argued that ‘this can only be done within a policy framework that finances and extends title to black South Africans’.

The risks of EWC as presently contemplated were exacerbated by the likely ramifications which ‘will extend far beyond the agricultural sector to many other spheres’, dampening foreign investment.

Cronje’s private and public engagements on EWC have included meetings with a former Assistant Secretary of State, a leading Africa policy advisor, senior journalists, the International Republican Institute, National Endowment for Democracy, American Enterprise Institute, and the Institute for International Finance.

He also had a meeting with SA Embassy diplomats, which he described as “excellent and constructive’.

Issued by the IRR, 22 June 2018